Research and development in private law

Research and development in private law

A comparative study of the nature of video games in the American legal system: an expressive medium or commercial product?

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Private and Islamic Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
2 Graduated with a master's degree in private law from the University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Should video games be considered a commercial product or an expressive medium? The answer to this question has important practical implications: if we consider the video game as a commercial product, the use of someone else's identity mark in it will undoubtedly face an injunction and compensation for damages, but if we consider it an expressive medium, Under the protection of the principle of freedom of speech, the injunction and compensation for the game company is a limitation of the freedom of speech and will not be met with a positive response by the judicial system. In the upcoming article, an attempt has been made to discuss the nature of the video game with the library method and to examine the possibility of choosing one of the two mentioned natures.
Keywords
Subjects

  1. Digregorio, Ch. (2017) “Finding a fair balance for the right of publicity and first amendment protections”, Touro law review, Vol. 33, No. 3, (2017)

    Grimes, CharlesW. & Gregory J. Battersby,(1979), "The Protection of Merchandising Properties",Trademark Reporter,vol.69,(1979)

    Gaetano, Dimita, , (2020)

     “Video games: flagships of digital colonialism or solitary beacons of creative freedomVideo games: flagships of digital colonialism or solitary beacons of creative freedom and diversity?”, Interactive Entertainment Law Review, vol. 3, (2020)

    Haemmerli, Alice. (1999) “Whose Who? The Case for a Kantian Right of Publicity”,Duke L.J.vol.49, (1999)

    Hollows, Allison L(2015). "The Application of the Transformative Use Test in the Right of Publicity Context", seton hall law, vol. 45, (2015)

    James A. Johnson,(2015),“The Right of Publicity and The Student-Athlete”, Elon Law Review,vol.7,(2015)

    Karcher, Richard T,“The Use of Player’s Indentities in Fantasy Sports League:Developing Workable Standards for Right of Publicity Claim”,Penn State Law Review,Penn state law review,vol.111.no.3,(2007)

    K.Ford, William "So Are Games Coffee Mugs or What? Games and the Right of Publicity Revisited",UIC Review of Intellectual Property,vol.19,(2020)

    K.Ford William & Raizel Liebler,"Games Are Not CoffeeMugs:Games and the Right of Publicity",Santa Clara High Technology Law Journal,volume 29,(2012)

    Lieberstein, Marc A. “Why a Reasonable Right of Publicity Should Survive Death: A Rebuttal”, Nysba Bright Ideas,vol.17,no2,(2008)

    PierreN. Leval, “Tward a Fair Use Standard”,HARV.law Rev,vol.103,(1990)

    Reaves, Cody."Show Me the Money: Determining a Celebrity’s Fair Market Value in a Right of Publicity Action", University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform,vol.70.no.3,(2017)

    Roooney, Susannah. M. “Just Another Brown-Eyed Girl: Toward A Limited Federal Right of publicity under the lanham act in a digital age of celebrity dominance”,Southern California Law Review,vol 86,(2013)

    Stim, Richard. “Fair Use: The Four Factors Courts Consider in a Copyright Infringement Case”, Available at: https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/fair-use-the-four-factors.html (Last visited on: 10/3/2024)

    Shyang Tseng, Yen. “Protecting the First Amendment Rights of Video Games from Lanham Act and Right of Publicity Claims”,Pepperdine Law Review,no.2,vol.48,(2021)

    1. Habiba, S., Hosseinzadeh, M., & Mohbi, S. (1395). Examining the fair use of another’s trademark to identify goods and services. Business Research Journal, (78) [volume and page numbers not provided]. (in Persian)
    2. Shakeri, Z. (1395). Infringement of literary and artistic rights through the parodic use of others’ literary and artistic works. Private Law, (28) [volume and page numbers not provided]. (in Persian)

    3. Shabiri, S. H. (1396). A comparative study of parody in literary and artistic works: A copyright purpose or copyright infringement? Theology of Art, 3(10) [page numbers not provided]. (in Persian)

    4. Mirshakari, A. (1399). The conflict between the rights of public figures and freedom of expression in the legal systems of the United States, France, Germany, and Iran. Justice Journal, (110) [volume and page numbers not provided]. (in Persian)

    5. Nazari, A., & Mirshakari, A. (1401). The value of reputation: A discussion of methods for compensating damage caused by the commercial exploitation of another’s reputation. Legal Studies, 21(49) [page numbers not provided]. (in Persian)

    6. Nazari, A., & Mirshakari, A. (1400). A comparative study of the exploitation of public figures’ reputations in video games. Private Law, 18(2) [page numbers not provided]. (in Persian)

    7. DiGregorio, C. (2017). Finding a fair balance for the right of publicity and First Amendment protections. Touro Law Review, 33(3).

    8. Grimes, C. W., & Battersby, G. J. (1979). The protection of merchandising properties. The Trademark Reporter, 69.

    9. Dimita, G. (2020). Video games: Flagships of digital colonialism or solitary beacons of creative freedom and diversity? Interactive Entertainment Law Review, 3.

    10. Haemmerli, A. (1999). Whose who? The case for a Kantian right of publicity. Duke Law Journal, 49.

    11. Hollows, A. L. (2015). The application of the transformative use test in the right of publicity context. Seton Hall Law Review, 45.

    12. Johnson, J. A. (2015). The right of publicity and the student-athlete. Elon Law Review, 7.

    13. Karcher, R. T. (2007). The use of players’ identities in fantasy sports leagues: Developing workable standards for right of publicity claims. Penn State Law Review, 111(3).

    14. Ford, W. (2020). So are games coffee mugs or what? Games and the right of publicity revisited. UIC Review of Intellectual Property Law, 19.

    15. Ford, W., & Liebler, R. (2012). Games are not coffee mugs: Games and the right of publicity. Santa Clara High Technology Law Journal, 29.

    16. Lieberstein, M. A. (2008). Why a reasonable right of publicity should survive death: A rebuttal. NYSBA Bright Ideas, 17(2).

    17. Leval, P. N. (1990). Toward a fair use standard. Harvard Law Review, 103.

    18. Reaves, C. (2017). Show me the money: Determining a celebrity’s fair market value in a right of publicity action. University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform, 70(3).

    19. Rooney, S. M. (2013). Just another brown-eyed girl: Toward a limited federal right of publicity under the Lanham Act in a digital age of celebrity dominance. Southern California Law Review, 86.

    20. Stim, R. (n.d.). Fair use: The four factors courts consider in a copyright infringement case. Nolo. Retrieved 10/3/2024, from https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/fair-use-the-four-factors.html

    21. Tseng, Y. S. (2021). Protecting the First Amendment rights of video games from Lanham Act and right of publicity claims. Pepperdine Law Review, 48(2).

Send comment about this article
Enter Name.
Enter a valid email address.
Enter a vaid affiliation.
Enter comments (At leaset 10 words)
CAPTCHA Image
Enter Security Code Correctly.