Research and development in private law

Research and development in private law

Enforcement Guarantee in Law and Public Policy: A Case Study of Article (1) of the "Act on the Mandatory Registration of Real Estate Transactions" (enacted in 2024)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD in Criminal Law and Criminology, Tehran University, Faculty of Law & Political Science, Tehran, Iran.
2 LLM from Farabi branch of Tehran University, Tehran, Iran
3 Assistant professor at Technology Studies Institute, Tehran, Iran
4 LLM Student in International Commercial and Economic law at Tehran University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
One of the most significant distinctions between the legal approach and the public policy approach to problem-solving lies in their respective perspectives on the design of enforcement guarantee. In this article, we aim to answer the question of what distinctions exist between the legal and public policy approaches to enforcement guarantee and which approach has been adopted in the design of the enforcement guarantee outlined in Article 1 of the "Act on the Mandatory Registration of Real Estate Transactions" (Enacted in 2024). This study, employing a qualitative legal methodology in the analysis of statutory text, and through using a public policy approach, examines the conceptual differences between law and public policy in the design of enforcement frameworks. Based on the policy-making process of the "Act on the Mandatory Registration of Real Estate Transactions" (Enacted in 2024), The findings demonstrate that exclusive reliance on traditional legal sanctions proves insufficient in addressing legal and judicial problems and may in fact result in secondary harms. The problem of the validity of informal (non-registered) documents constitutes one of the fundamental challenges within Iran’s legal and judicial system, with its detrimental effects extending across various levels and areas of public policy. The analysis of the "Act on the Mandatory Registration of Real Estate Transactions" (Enacted in 2024) as the case study of this research highlights the adoption of a public policy perspective in the design of the enforcement mechanism stipulated in Article 1 of the Act, which diverges from the conventional reliance on criminal sanctions a pattern extensively observed in Iran's public policy processes. In this case, the design of the enforcement guarantee reflects a shift from traditional criminalization toward a policy-based sanction, namely inadmissibility of claims. Since the issuance of inadmissibility orders has not been explicitly stipulated in previous Iranian legislation and has largely been developed through judicial practice, the enforcement guarantee introduced in Article 1 constitutes the first explicit legislative recognition of the inadmissibility of a specific claim. The findings of this study indicate that addressing public issues within the legal and judicial domain such as the validity of ordinary documentsrequires moving beyond traditional legal frameworks and adopting interdisciplinary approaches, particularly legal policy-making as a branch of public policy. An approach that utilizes the principles and techniques of public policy to enhance both the quality of the policy-making process in legal and judicial affairs, as well as improve the quality of its outputs in the form of overarching documents, laws, and regulations.
Keywords

1.     Becker, G. S. (1968). Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach. Journal of Political Economy, 76(2), 169–217.
2.     Cairney, Paul. (2020). Understanding Public Policy: Theories and Issues (Vol. 2). London: Bloomsbury Publishing.
3.     Dror, I.E. (2020). Cognitive and human factors in expert decision making: Six fallacies and the eight sources of bias. Analytical Chemistry, 92(12), 7998-8004.
4.     Garner, B. A. (1999). Black’s Law Dictionary (7th ed.). New York: St. Paul Minn.
5.     Howlett, Michael. (Ed.). (2023). The Routledge Handbook of Policy Tools. Abingdon: Routledge.
6.     Kay, F. M. (2004). Professionalism and exclusionary practices: Shifting the terrain of privilege and professional monopoly. International Journal of the Legal Profession, 11(1–2), 11–20.
7.     Knake, R.N. (2018). The Legal Monopoly. Washington Law Review, 93 (3), 1293-1337.
8.     Levy-Carciente, Sary Montanari, & Lorenzo. (2024). International Property Rights Index 2024 (Full Report). Property Rights Alliance.
9.     Neal, T., Lienert, P., Denne, E., & Singh, J.P. (2022). A general model of cognitive bias in human judgment and systematic review specific to forensic mental health. Law and Human Behavior, 46(2), 99-120.
10.  Rinfret, S. R. (Ed.). (2024). Street-Level Public Servants: Case Studies for a New Generation of Public Administration (1st ed.). London: Routledge.
11.  Shamir, R. (1993). Professionalism and Monopoly of Expertise: Lawyers and Administrative Law, 1933–1937. Law & Society Review, 27(2), 361-397.
References       
1.     Abdolmaleki, M. Shakouri Gorkani, M. (2022). Report on the Parliament’s Plan to Obligate the Official Registration of Real Estate Transactions. Tehran: Legal Studies Office of the Parliamentary Research Center. [In Persian].
2.     Abdollah Zadeh Shahrebabaki, Azadeh. (2021). An Introduction to the Quality of Law. Tehran: Public Shareholding Company. [In Persian].
3.     Abdolmaleki, M. Shakouri Gorkani, M. (2022). Report on the Parliament’s Plan to Obligate the Official Registration of Real Estate Transactions. Tehran: Legal Studies Office of the Parliamentary Research Center. [In Persian].Ahmadzadeh, Rasoul. Mashayekhi, Zahra. (2022). Criminal Titles with a New
4.     Alijani, Mohsen. Javaherkalam, Mohammad Hadi. (2024). Economical and legal analysis of article 1 of the mandatory formal registration of immovable propertie. Tehran: Encyclopedia of Economic Law Journal. Doi:
10.22067/economlaw.2024.89080.1386 [In Persian].
5.     Ahmadzadeh, Rasoul. Mashayekhi, Zahra. (2022). Criminal Titles with a New Classification. Tehran: Judicial System Press and Publications Center. [In Persian].
6.     Ameri Sani, Amirkia. (2024). Problem-oriented Criminal Policy in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Mizan. [In Persian].
7.     Ashoori, Mohammad. Sabouri Pour, Mehdi. (2015). Comparison of the impact of severity and certainty of imprisonment on its deterrent effect. Criminal Law and Criminology Studies, 2(2-3), 1-17. Doi: JQCLCS-201508-1045. [In Persian].
8.     Ashtarian, Kioomars. (2018). Guideline for Policy Making. Tehran: Bazargani Publication. [In Persian].
9.     Bahremand, Hamid. Ameri Sani, Amirkia. Farahmand, Azar. Hajizadeh, Amirhosein. (2023). Legal policy making and prevention of dispersed judicial decisions: reducing the range of interpretations for rules by using explanatory notes and a judicial laboratory. Legal Journal of Judiciary. 87 (125). 71-107. [In Persian].
10.  Becker, G. S. (1968). Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach. Journal of Political Economy, 76(2), 169–217. http://www.jstor.org/stable/1830482
11.  Cairney, Paul. (2020). Understanding Public Policy: Theories and Issues (Vol. 2). London: Bloomsbury Publishing.
12.  Darvishi, Bank. Zeynali Aghdam, Amirali. (2014). The nature of administrative sanctions in the legal system of Iran. Comparative Legal Research in Iran and International Law, 25, 36-58. [In Persian].
13.  Dror, I.E. (2020). Cognitive and human factors in expert decision making: Six fallacies and the eight sources of bias. Analytical Chemistry, 92(12), 7998-8004.
14.  Enserink, Bert, Hermans, Leon, Kwakl, Jan, Tison, Wil, Koupinian, Joop, & Bats, Peter. (2022). Policy Analysis in Multi-Actor Systems (R. Hassan, B. Behdani & L. Namdarian, Trans.). Tehran: Samt Publishing. [In Persian].
1.     Strategic planning deputy of the Iranian Judiciary. (2023). Examining the proposed theories to invalidate informal transaction. Report, 2-7. [In Persian].
15.  Garland, David. (2018). The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society (H. R. Malek Mohammadi, Trans.). Tehran: Mizan Publishing. [In Persian].
16.  Garner, B. A. (1999). Black’s Law Dictionary (7th ed.). New York: St. Paul Minn.
17.  Gholami, Hossein. (2017). Penology. Tehran: Mizan Publishing. [In Persian].
18.  Howlett, Michael. (Ed.). (2023). The Routledge Handbook of Policy Tools. Abingdon: Routledge.
19.  Irvanian, Amir. (2012). General Theory of Criminal Policy. Tehran: Shahredanesh. [In Persian].
20.  Jafarilangrudi, Mohammad Jafar. (1967). Legal Terminology. Tehran: Ibne Sina Publication. [In Persian].
21.  Jafarilangrudi, Mohammad Jafar. (2008). General Introduction in Law. Tehran: Ganjedanesh Publication. [In Persian].
22.  Katouzian, Nasser. (2013). Introduction to the Science of Law and Study of the Legal System of Iran. Tehran: Public Shareholding Company. [In Persian].
23.  Kay, F. M. (2004). Professionalism and exclusionary practices: Shifting the terrain of privilege and professional monopoly. International Journal of the Legal Profession, 11(1–2), 11–20. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/0969595042000317398
24.  Khodadad, Janat. Amini, Mansoor. (2022). Evaluation of the “Obligation to Officially Register Real Estate Transactions” Plan with a Comparative Approach. Journal of Registration Law Research, 1, 181-214. Doi: 10.22106/rlr.2021.523591.1022. [In Persian].
25.  Khoroushi, Abdolazim. (2024). Pre-emption Right as a Strategy to Preserve Agricultural Lands: A Comparative Study with the European Union. Comparative Law Research and Development Quarterly, 7(25), 46-75.
https://doi.org/10.22034/law.2024.2038115.1441. [In Persian].
26.  Knake, R.N. (2018). The Legal Monopoly. Washington Law Review, 93, 1293.
27.  Levy-Carciente, Sary Montanari, & Lorenzo. (2024). International Property Rights Index 2024 (Full Report). Property Rights Alliance.
28.  Majchrzak, Ann. (2019). Methods for policy research (H. Nayebi, Trans.). Tehran: Ney Publishing. [In Persian].
29.  Malekmohammadi, Hamidreza. (2020). Policies to Tackle Crime and Corruption (2nd ed.). Tehran: Samt Publication. [In Persian].
30.  Mirshkari, Abbas. Zargari, Jamshid. (2024). The Mirror Principle in the Land Registration System of England and Iran. Comparative Law Research and Development Quarterly, 7(24), 204-238. https://doi.org/10.22034/law.2024.2026792.1328. [In Persian].
31.  Mirzaei, Eghbal Ali. (2011). Abandoned law: Foundations, concepts, and examples. The legal Journal of judiciary, 75(74), 69-102. [In Persian].
32.  Muller, Pierre. (1999). Public Policy (H. R. Malek Mohammadi, Trans.). Tehran: Dadgostar Publishing. [In Persian].
33.  Najafi Abrand Abadi, Ali Hossein. Hashem Beiki, Hamid. (20112018). Encyclopedia of Criminology. Tehran: Ganj Danesh Publishing. [In Persian].
34.  Neal, T., Lienert, P., Denne, E., & Singh, J.P. (2022). A general model of cognitive bias in human judgment and systematic review specific to forensic mental health. Law and Human Behavior, 46(2), 99.
35.  Niazpour, Amirhosein, (2020), State Actors in Legal Policy-Making in: Encyclopedia of Legal Policy-Making, Editors: Laya Joneydi & Amirhosein Niazpour, First Edition, Tehran, Codification Deputy of Presidency.
36.  Omravani, Rahman. (2008). Examining the conflict of official documents with ordinary documents. Kanoon Journal, 81-82, 51-65. [In Persian].
37.  Parsons, Wayne. (2021). An Introduction to the Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis (H. R. Malekmohammadi, Trans.). Tehran: Strategic Studies Research Center. [In Persian].
38.  Parvini, Kheyrallah, Faramarazi, Reza, Pashayi Amiri, Amin. (2020). Codification of laws and regulations: A step in ensuring the principle of legal security. Public Law Knowledge Quarterly, 30, 95-116. Doi:10.22034/qjplk.2020.212. [In Persian].
39.  Reinerson, Arthur G. (2020). Legislative Drafting, Step-by-Step (A. Abdollahi Zadeh Shahrebabaki, Trans.). Tehran: Samt Publishing. [In Persian].
40.  Rinfret, S. R. (Ed.). (2024). Street-Level Public Servants: Case Studies for a New Generation of Public Administration (1st ed.). London: Routledge.
41.  Saber, M. Tabatabaee Hesaree, Nasrin. (2011). THE LEGAL AND ECONOMIC EFFECTS OF THE SYSTEM OF REGISTRATION REAL PROPERTIES. Law Quarterly, 41(2), 115-129. [In Persian].
42.  Shafritz, Jay M., & Brick, Christopher. (2011). Public Policy in the United States (H. R. Malek Mohammadi, Trans.). Tehran: Imam Sadiq University Publishing. [In Persian].
43.  Shahnoosh Foroshani, Mohammad Abdol Saleh. (2016). Cancellation of official ownership document based on ordinary sale document with prior date (Critique of the judgment of the Tehran Court of Appeals). Judicial verdict Journal (Quarterly), 5(14). [In Persian].
44.  Shams, Abdollah. (2010). Civil Procedure (Volume One) (Advanced Course). Tehran: Derak. [In Persian]
45.  Shamir, R. (1993). Professionalism and Monopoly of Expertise: Lawyers and Administrative Law, 1933–1937. Law & Society Review, 27(2), 361-397. Doi:10.2307/3053942.
46.  Strategic planning deputy of the Iranian Judiciary. (2023). Examining the proposed theories to invalidate informal transaction. Report, 2-7. [In Persian].
47.  Tabatabaee Hesaree, Nasrin. (2010). COMPARATIVE CONSIDERATION OF LAND REGISTRATION SYSTEMS WITH EMPHASIS ON IRANIAN LAND REGISTRATION SYSTEM. Law Quarterly, 40(2), 219-237. [In Persian].
48.  Xanthaki, Helen. (2021). Legislative Technology: Art, Technology, and Regulatory Rules (H. Vakilian, Trans.). Tehran: Samt Publishing. [In Persian].
Send comment about this article
Enter Name.
Enter a valid email address.
Enter a vaid affiliation.
Enter comments (At leaset 10 words)
CAPTCHA Image
Enter Security Code Correctly.