Research and development in private law

Research and development in private law

Comparative Study of the Moral Damage of the Deceased in Islamic and Western Law

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Private and Islamic Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
2 Master's degree in Private Law from the University of Judicial Sciences, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Person's credit has an existence beyond his life; An impressionable creature that can be harmed even after the death of human being, therefore needs legal protection; In American law's literature, tried to emphasize the possibility of recognizing the deceased as victim by backward causation; However, given that deceased is incapacitated and doesn't have ability to understand and be aware of what happened after his death; He can hardly be considered as a victim. In this direction, European law has also focused on the fact that the heir is the victim; However, although they can claim the loss that they personally suffered from damage to deceased's reputation, but when fundamentally we didn't consider deceased himself rightful, how can we consider his heirs as his successors? According to these points, it seems that the main damage from harm to deceased's credit is to the society, Because the peace of mind of community members will be disturbed by damage to people's dignity who Formerly alive in this society like all living members and understand feelings and emotions; and collective interest in preserving deceased's dignity will be harmed; In this way, by considering society as beneficiary, its members are assured that not only such behavior will not be repeated towards the deceased's moral rights, But rather spiritual sanctity of each member of the society will never be attacked after their death. Therefore, it seems that in Iranian law, it's preferable to consider society as entitled to deceased's privacy and use the compensation received from the cause of loss in way of public interest by using the capacity of Article‌‌ 103 of Non Litigious Jurisdiction‌ Act.
Keywords
Subjects

1.       Allen, Anita L. & Rothman, Jennifer E. (2024). Postmortem Privacy. Michigan Law Review, 123. (Allen & Rothman, 2024)
2.       Baier, Annette (2010). Reflections on how we live. Oxford: Oxford University Press. (Baier, 2010)
3.       Biederman, Donald (2011). Law and business of the entertainment industries. Westford: Praeger Publishers. (Biederman, 2011)
4.       Black, Max (1956). Why Cannot an Effect Precede Its Cause?. Analysis, 16(2). (Black, 1956)
5.       Butnariu, M., Sarac, I. (2019). Biochemistry of Hormones that Influences Feelings. Ann Pharmacovigil Drug Saf., 1(1). (Butnariu & Sarac, 2019)
6.       Faye, Jan (2021). Backward Causation. Retrieved from https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2021/entries/causation-backwards/. (Faye, 2021)
7.       Feldman, Fred (1991). Some Puzzles About the Evil of Death. The Philosophical Review, 100(1). (Feldman, 1991)
8.       Feinberg, Joel (1980). Rights, Justice, and the Bounds of Liberty. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. (Feinberg, 1980)
9.       Grover, Doroth (1950). Posthumous Harm. The Philosophical Quarterly, 39(156). (Grover, 1950)
10.    Luper, Steven (2014). The Cambridge Companion to Life and Death. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. (Luper, 2014)
11.    Lieberstein, M.A. (2008). Why a Reasonable Right of Publicity Should Survive Death: A Rebuttal. NYSBA Bright Ideas, 17(2). (Lieberstein, 2008)
12.    McCutcheon, Jani (2015). Death Rights: Legal Personal Representatives of Deceased Authors and the Posthumous Exercise of Moral Rights. Intellectual Property Quarterly; Mytholmroyd: Sweet & Maxwell. (McCutcheon, 2015)
13.    McCutcheon, Jani (2016). Dead Loss: Damages for Posthumous Breach of the Moral Right of Integrity. Melbourne University Law Review, 40(1). (McCutcheon, 2016)
14.    O’Callaghan, S.T., Ramos, F.T. (2012). Gaussian Process Occupancy Maps. The International Journal of Robotics Research, 31(1). (O’Callaghan & Ramos, 2012)
15.    Partridge, Ernest (1981). Posthumous Interests and Posthumous Respect. Ethics, 91(2). (Partridge, 1981)
16.    Pitcher, George (1984). The Misfortunes of the Dead. American Philosophical Quarterly, 21(2). (Pitcher, 1984)
17.    Portmore, Douglas W. (2007). Desire Fulfillment and Posthumous Harm. American Philosophical Quarterly, 44(1). (Portmore, 2007)
18.    Smolensky, Kirsten Rabe (2009). Rights of the Dead. Hofstra Law Review, 37. (Smolensky, 2009)
19.    Sperling, Daniel (2008). Posthumous Interests: Legal and Ethical Perspective. Cambridge University Press, New York, US. (Sperling, 2008)
20.    Sugarman, S. D. (1985). Doing Away with Tort Law. California Law Review, 73(3). (Sugarman, 1985)
21.    Tomasini, Floris (2009). Is Post-Mortem Harm Possible? Understanding Death Harm and Grief. American Philosophical Quarterly, vol. 23, no. 8. (Tomasini, 2009)
22.    Tomasini, Floris (2017). Remembering and Disremembering the Dead: Posthumous Punishment, Harm and Redemption over Time. London: Springer Nature. (Tomasini, 2017)
23.    Wilkinson, T.M. (2014). Respect for the Dead and the Ethics of Anatomy. Clin Anat, 27(3). (Wilkinson, 2014)
24.    Young, H. (2013). The Right To Posthumous Bodily Integrity And Implications Of Whose Right It Is. Marquette Elder’s Advisor, 14(2). (Young, 2013)
Send comment about this article
Enter Name.
Enter a valid email address.
Enter a vaid affiliation.
Enter comments (At leaset 10 words)
CAPTCHA Image
Enter Security Code Correctly.